In April 2000, teenagers Jeremy Bechtel and Erin Foster vanished after leaving a party in Erin’s Pontiac Grand Am in Sparta, Tennessee. Jeremy had called his father that night to say he would stay over, but by the next morning, both teens and Erin’s car had disappeared without a trace. Despite extensive searches and community efforts, the case went cold, haunting the small town for over two decades. In 2021, YouTuber Jeremy Sides, known for investigating cold cases near waterways, revisited the